Paul's Live From New York Pizza
Restaurant on Diners, Drive-Ins & Dives

Watch episode 'All Things New York' aired on season 19

Locations Guy Fieri visits in the USA - Places to eat comfort home-style, healthy, gourmet & fast food meals!


When not in New York, the best place to get an authentic pie is in this popping joint in California. The owner Paul, came from the Jersey to spread the old school, real deal east coast pizza slices to the masses! Each pie is made by a true artist and you'll never try another slice once you dine here. Opened up in 2005, it's been growing in popularity ever since and we highly recommend it. It all comes down to the simplicity of the sauce combined with the thin and crispy crust. The two hot choices from the menu include the Margarita Pizza which include thick garlic cloves as the finishing touch. Also, their thick crust, deep dish square pie is a delight as well. Crispy, crunch, fried at the bottom, you'll eat every crumb!

Address / Location

604 F Street
Eureka, CA 95501

Live From New York Pizza on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives

Menu Recommendations

Cuisine / Diet Plan with Popular Foods & Meals to Eat Here

Italian Food Pizza

Chicken Club Sicilian Pizza Pizza Slice with Salad The Sunset and Olive Special Pauls Live From New York Pizza Food Garlic Twists Hawaiian Pizza Slice Wall St. Sicilian Crust Pizza Chicken Club Pizza

For menu, health nutrition facts, hours,
delivery, reservations or gift cards please call.

Diet-friendly, vegan, gluten free or
organic meals may be available.

Guide: Diners Drive-Ins & Dives in Eureka, CA